Law School Dreamin’ By An 8th Grader



The sun will rise in the east every morning. We will have the opportunity to elect a new leader of our country every four years. Kanye West will say something dumb by the end of the year. Those are occurrences we naturally expect. But here’s something more unexpected: a letter from a middle schooler showing up on a law school dean’s desk.

The residual effects of the Great Recession, coupled with rising student debt and stagnant incomes –have all made many would-be law students hesitate before taking out a school loan. So you can imagine how shocked Dean Nick Allard of Brooklyn Law School was when he opened this letter in November.

For privacy purposes, let’s refer to the student as Greg. Greg’s letter had one request:

“I plan to study law and am inquiring about the majors you offer for this field. I am looking for a college with great advisory and counseling to help set me on the right path and direction to become a successful law student and someday a defense attorney.”

Whoa. Most eighth graders are filling their lockers with stolen bags of chips or passing notes that end with “check yes, no, or maybe.” Instead, Greg was seeking advice from a respected dean.


Despite receiving the letter about a year after it was sent, Allard replied on November 25.  And the lessons he shared could be applied to an aspiring law student of any age. Allard began his response by citing some of his heroic fictional lawyer inspirations—Atticus Finch and Perry Mason. Yes, there is still a essence of romanticism in the law profession. The crux of Allard’s response to Greg came next and is a testament to Greg’s courage and drive.

“The simple answer is that to prepare to be a great lawyer: Study something you love hard, dig deep, and know it matters not what particular field of study you choose prior to law school. Any excellent intellectual grounding you acquire will serve the purpose. English, History, Philosophy, Physics, Political Science, or Music will open untold doors to you as a lawyer if that is who you want to become. The lawyer’s muscle—the brain—is the greatest tool known to mankind and you may sharpen that tool with hard work in any and all of the wide array of academic disciplines that the human intellect encompasses and pursues.”

Then Allard provided quotes from other attorneys in American history who were “a lot smarter” than him. Joseph Story spoke of the importance of searching the human heart and knowing the sources of passions for as many as possible. He also spoke of knowing the history and tendencies of humankind. Attorneys must know humankind. And that comes from learning, which often comes from reading. “And, Greg, reading is truly the key,” Allard points out in his return letter.

Allard cites President Abraham Lincoln: “If you wish to be a lawyer, attach no consequence to the place you are in, or the person you are with; but get books, sit down anywhere, and go to reading for yourself.” Those are intense words for an eighth grader.


In a letter largely made up of an array of quotes from some of the country’s legal crackerjacks, Allard continued to offer wisdom through the voices of justices past. Former Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, Louis Brandeis said overcoming difficulties and struggles in academia and life will strengthen the mind and will of a person more than favorable conditions. And attorneys will fall on hard times. Another former Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, Felix Frankfurter, said being a great lawyer means reading great poetry and seeing paintings and listening to music and experiencing the “mysteries of the universe.” It is the unknown that reveals truths.

And finally, according to Allard, the final piece of becoming a great lawyer is communication. In particular, being able to communicate effectively and succinctly. Allard closes his letter to the now freshman in high school with a quote from Thomas Jefferson.

“Your resolution to apply to the study of the law is wise in my opinion … The study of the law is useful in a variety of points of view. It qualifies a man to be useful to himself, to his neighbors, and to the public…”

With a profession in flux, Allard says this is the time for everyone in the legal education community to consider two questions. Why should anyone study law? And how do you best prepare to study law. It might have taken an eighth grader to remind Allard of the importance of those questions. Nevertheless, Greg got a response that was probably more than he bargained for. Perhaps he will be the one quoted in future letters from deans to other aspiring law students.


  • davidlocke

    When I was a kid, I wanted to be an architect. There were no books telling a kid how to become an architect. I would have taken drafting. That would not have been how to become an architect. I didn’t find this out until I was an adult and a long way from being an architect. It’s a good thing that this kid is trying to find out how to get where he is going.
    I recently heard some college kid talk about going to law school, but in that conversation were hints that the kid didn’t know zip about it. They hadn’t take debate in high school. They didn’t know what got taught in the high school government class. They just saw lawyering on TV. Most of that is a long way from lawyering. The kid was a woman. She had talked to no woman attorney’s either. She has no idea about what her life would be like if she got a good corporate law job out of law school. I had a woman attorney as a boss. She had her lament’s as her career limited her outcomes in her personal life. Talk to everyone about your goals. Consider changing your goals.

    • Nathan Allen

      Thanks, David. That’s some good advice. The younger these questions are asked, the better, I think.

      • EPOC

        I am not so sure. Young minds should be engrossed in opening the doors of their brains, not something as mundane as career planning! Becoming the best person they can be is more paramount and becomes less malleable over time. As society gets more developed so should the freedom to think and apply oneself in a myriad of ways. Yet it seems our progress is in greater and greater compartmentalisation and earlier career planning – as is in a third world country!

        • TimeandMoneyarealwaysShort

          Yes, children should dream, but they shouldn’t pursue something that they never actually wanted to pursue simply because they are under a misconception of what it actually is. With specific reference to law, I have seen many people realize that they don’t like law or don’t actually want a career in law long after they are in law school. While I’m of the opinion that studying law will always benefit you no matter what you end up doing, not everyone can afford to spend that much time and money.

          • EPOC

            Nor should they pursue something merely because school and society say it is worthy.

  • Suicidal_JD

    Law school ruined my life! I have no job and I have student loan debt that will follow me to my grave. Now is a horrible time to go to law school. DO NOT GO TO LAW SCHOOL!