Why Do So Many People Despise Law School?

WE NEVER PROMISED A WELL-PAYING JOB
Since the 1970s, an intellectual movement by the name of “law and economics” has steadily crept through law schools, Winterhalter says. The idea is that the law’s usefulness should be measured by how smoothly it lets the market function. “I think that ideological shift means that it’s often very difficult for people to feel able to critique law school, because they sort of go to law school and they hear, ‘Oh, it’s the free market, everyone makes choices, I made a choice to go to law school, you get what you get,'” he explains. “There’s something very seductive about that sort of thinking, but it also leads to some people feeling kind of powerless…. There’s this whole complex repressed anger, and I think that comes out.”
Corkery maintains that getting a well-paying job has never been part of the deal at John Marshall or any other law school. “We never promised that, and don’t promise it,” he says. “What we promise is that you get a really good legal education that can serve you well for the rest of your life.”
Schools aren’t fairy godmothers with the power to bestow sparkly jobs upon all of their graduates. But placing little weight on the fact that professional schools exist to help people enter a profession — to help people move up in the world — amounts to willful ignorance. Why else would employment rates factor into every popular school ranking? (For the record, only 18.7% of John Marshall’s class of 2011 was employed at graduation, according to U.S. News).
Even worse, Corkery’s statement is at odds with the account of Amy Cramer, a John Marshall graduate who left with $250,000 in loans and spent almost two years without full-time work; she just recently started her own firm. She owes much of her staggering debt to an LL.M. she pursued in employee benefits. “I was certainly led to believe that employee benefits was the wave of the future with Obamacare, and that people would be knocking down my door to get me to work for them,” Cramer says. “And that has not happened. I don’t know if it’s a matter of time, but I don’t see those jobs out there for Obamacare, and so that has certainly been a disappointment.”
So, then, if getting a legal education isn’t about getting a job, why bother selling it like it is?
HOW LAW SCHOOL IS LIKE THE BACHELOR
J.D.s certainly don’t come cheap. It’s almost unheard of to attend law school without taking out significant loans. What’s more, the average debt load is mounting: in 2001-2002, JDs borrowed on average $46,500 at public law schools and $70,000 at private law schools; by 2011, those numbers rose to $75,700 and $125,000, respectively.
If you think the debt is spread around evenly, think again. “The financial aid structure at so many law schools is exactly the reverse of what it is at just about any other educational institution,” Winterhalter says. “The bottom of the entering class — which tends to be women, tends to be minorities, tends to be people from disadvantaged socioeconomic backgrounds — effectively subsidizes the top of the class, who get merit-based scholarships.” In the scramble for higher rankings, law schools focus on reeling in high-scoring candidates rather than helping students who might need it most.
This starting point doesn’t contribute to warm feelings for law school, which is a notoriously strange atmosphere to begin with. Winterhalter says it’s a lot like the reality show “The Bachelor.” “Everyone sort of pretends to get along, but it’s very clear that beneath the veneer, there’s a sort of lingering tension that comes from people’s competitive drive,” he says.
And if the law school of your dreams says it’s not like the others, you might want to take that claim with a grain of salt. “There’s a saying at Boston College that it’s the Disneyland of law schools,” Winterhalter says. “Apparently, it’s supposed to be a metaphor for how nice and friendly and warm and welcoming it is. To me, this is the … the perfect metaphor for how sort of phony people are about the fact that they’re being competitive. At the end of the day, it’s still a rigidly hierarchical school. It’s graded on a curve. Only a certain number of people can get in. There are big classes where people are fighting to be at the top, and it seems like that social dynamic is just too powerful to be completely overridden, no matter how hard you try to be nice.”
THE PERFECT STORM
When competitive people work hard and don’t get what they want, the result isn’t pretty. “I think that often, they feel like what they thought was a mode of moving up in the world ends up just sort of stagnating them economically, and I think that, broadly speaking, people feel sort of bitter about that,” Winterhalter says. “That certainly makes people more receptive to critiques of law school and to ideological examinations of what’s going on.”
So, there you have it: Law school’s perfect storm. As an educational institution, it admits highly ambitious students, pits them against each other with little attempt to level the financial playing field, and releases them into a market that can’t absorb them. When students struggle, schools shrug and say they never guaranteed employment in the first place.
GO TO A CHEAP PUBLIC SCHOOL, ADVISES A DEAN
But there’s some evidence that law schools are taking steps to put out the fires. In the past few months, schools such as the University of Iowa, Penn State, and Roger Williams University have cut tuition.
Even Corkery has some disarmingly practical advice for prospective lawyers. “You know, you might not be able to afford to go where you want to,” he says. “I think tuition from public schools to private runs from around $13,000 to $16,000 a year, up to probably $56,000 to $57,000.” Full-time tuition at John Marshall is $41,304 per year.
“Now, where are those low-tuition law schools?” he adds. “They’re just in pockets across the country. One thing you might do is explore schools with lower tuition and see if you can get admitted and work out financing to go there.”
Institutional reforms aside, maybe the best first step is a little more real talk.

Questions about this article? Email us or leave a comment below.